Why do I second-guess myself?

You make a decision, but instead of feeling settled, you start wondering if you got it wrong.

Maybe the other option was better. Maybe you should ask someone else. Maybe you should change your mind.

Sometimes the difficult part is not making the decision. It is trusting yourself after you have made it.

What second-guessing can look like

Second-guessing can happen with big decisions, but it can also show up in small everyday choices.

  • Changing your mind soon after making a choice.
  • Asking several people what they think.
  • Looking for signs that you made the right decision.
  • Thinking about what might have happened if you chose differently.
  • Feeling unsure even when you had a good reason for your choice.
  • Wanting someone else to confirm that you did the right thing.

Why can you keep questioning your decisions?

Sometimes you second-guess yourself because you want to avoid making a mistake.

You may also care a lot about how your choice affects other people. If someone seems disappointed or disagrees with you, that can make a decision you felt comfortable with suddenly feel less certain.

Asking for another opinion can be useful. But if each new opinion makes it harder to hear your own, you may end up feeling less clear than before.

A few things to notice

What made this choice feel right when I first made it?
Did something new happen, or did I simply start feeling unsure?
Am I asking for useful advice, or hoping someone will make the decision feel safe for me?
Would I still question this choice if nobody else knew about it?

A different opinion does not always mean your choice was wrong

Someone else may have chosen differently from you. That does not automatically make their choice better.

People make decisions based on different needs, priorities and situations. Advice can help you see another point of view, but you are still the person who has to live with the choice.

It can help to notice when another person's reaction starts to matter more than the reasons you had for making your own decision.

Notice what happens after you decide

One difficult decision does not necessarily mean you have a pattern of doubting yourself.

But if you often make a choice and then begin checking, comparing or asking for reassurance, that may be useful to notice.

Looking back across different decisions can help you see what tends to bring the doubt back and whether the same response keeps appearing.

Related

Notice what happens after you make a choice.

RealWithin gives you a place to reflect on everyday decisions, doubts and reactions. As your Reflections build over time, it can help you notice whether the same kind of self-doubt keeps returning.

Try RealWithin

No account needed for the preview.

RealWithin is for personal reflection, not medical or mental health advice.